信息安全研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 8 ›› Issue (4): 408-.

• 数据安全治理专题 • 上一篇    

互联网平台数据权属治理的法律探讨

王凌月;   

  1. 上海大学法学院
    上海200444
  • 出版日期:2022-04-10 发布日期:2022-04-10
  • 通讯作者: 王凌月 硕士研究生.主要研究方向为知识产权. wvalerie1230@163.com
  • 作者简介:王凌月 硕士研究生.主要研究方向为知识产权. wvalerie1230@163.com

Legal Discussion on Internet Platform Data Ownership Governance

  • Online:2022-04-10 Published:2022-04-10

摘要: 二维火诉美团不正当竞争纠纷案引发了一场SaaS领域的“3Q大战”,两法院针对同一案情却作出完全相反的判决,其矛盾的根源在于对互联网平台数据的财产权益归属认定不清.在我国尚未设立数据权的前提下,以设立数据权为进路的解决方式存在诸多困境,易导致法律僵化反而不利于市场的良好运行.而竞争法领域内多原则并存,认定标准模糊不清.因此,应在现行法律框架内解决该问题,从竞争法视角考量影响互联网平台数据财产权益归属的5个因素:用户数据的性质、互联网平台对数据的贡献程度、互联网平台加工数据的用途、第三方平台获取数据的主观目的和实质效果以及以数据权益划分后对消费者利益、市场竞争秩序和社会公共利益的影响进行审查和认定.关键词数据;权益归属;互联网平台;不正当竞争;五因素分析

关键词: 数据, 权益归属, 互联网平台, 不正当竞争, 五因素分析

Abstract: The twodimensional fire v. Meituan unfair competition dispute triggered a “3Q war” in the SaaS field. The two courts made completely opposite judgments on the same case. The source of the contradiction lies in the failure to determine the ownership of the property rights of Internet platform data clear. Under the premise that my country has not established data rights, there are many dilemmas in the solution of establishing data rights, which can easily lead to legal rigidity, which is not conducive to the good operation of the market.  In the field of competition law, many principles coexist, and the criteria for identification are vague. Therefore, this issue should be resolved within the current legal framework, and from the perspective of competition law, five factors that affect the ownership of Internet platform data property rights should be considered: the nature of user data, the degree of contribution of Internet platform to data, the subjective purpose and substantive effects of data obtained by thirdparty platforms and the actual effect of using the data and after the data rights are divided, the impact of consumer interests, market competition order and social public interests will be reviewed and determined.Key words data; ownership of rights; Internet platform; unfair competition; five factor analysis

Key words: data, ownership of rights, Internet platform, unfair competition, five factor analysis